Justice for Eli

The Record / The Closing

United States v. Elizabeth Hernandez · from the trial transcript

30 minutes to answer for 20 years

At Elizabeth Hernandez's federal trial, the judge gave the prosecution 40 minutes for closing argument and gave her lawyer 30. A federal appeals court later ruled that was an abuse of discretion. Her 20-year sentence stands anyway. Here is that closing, minute by minute, from the official transcript.

By Evelyn Hernandez, her sister · November 10, 2026 · Justice and the Record

40minutes for the prosecution
30minutes for the defense
240months in prison

THE CLOCKWatch it run

Every quotation below is from the transcript of the last day of trial, docket entry 149. Press play to see the closing arguments in the order the jury heard them. Record

Prosecution40:00
010203040 min
Defense30:00
010203040 min
ArgumentRebuttal, 4.5 minRequested & refused
Showing the full record.
  1. That morning
    DE 149:57

    The time limits are set the day of closings.

    The court gives the government 40 minutes and the defense 30. Rebuttal comes out of the government's share: That is included in the 40. Defense counsel objects that she learned of the limit that morning.

  2. Late in the first closing
    DE 149:83

    With 40 minutes, the prosecutor is rushing.

    I am moving a little faster, frankly, because I am running out of time.

  3. 35:30
    DE 149:104

    The government's first closing ends.

    It ran 35 and a half minutes — five and a half minutes longer than everything the defense would be allowed to say.

  4. Defense minute 30
    DE 149:103

    Her lawyer is cut off in the middle of a sentence.

    She asks for ten more minutes three times and is refused each time. Then she asks: Can I just give closing remarks? The court: Your time is up.

  5. Rebuttal, 4:30
    DE 149:106

    The government speaks last, and adds a theory.

    In its final four and a half minutes the prosecution argues “deliberate avoidance”: that Elizabeth is guilty even if she did not actually know. In the transcript that theory appears only here, after the defense has been silenced. The court then instructs the jury on it.

  6. Jury charge
    DE 149:122

    The judge misreads who must prove good faith.

    Good faith was her whole defense. One word changed when the instruction was read aloud. The government later conceded the error.

    Written instruction

    A defendant isn't required to prove good faith.

    Read to the jury

    A defendant is required to prove good faith.

  7. After the jury leaves
    DE 149:129

    Ten subjects the jury never heard the defense argue.

    Counsel puts on the record what she could not reach:

    false statementsCounts 8–10the amount paidthe defense's only witnessElizabeth's own statementsdeliberate ignorancethe key cooperatorlack of evidencepatientsgood faith
  8. Verdict
    DE 149:139

    The jury did not accept everything it was told.

    Jurors sent a note saying they could not find paperwork for two patients, then acquitted Elizabeth on two health care fraud counts. They convicted on eight.

THE RULINGThe appeals court agreed it was wrong

Court heldOn July 31, 2026, the Eleventh Circuit held that the uneven split was an abuse of discretion. The only reason the trial judge gave was that the government carries the burden of proof — which is true in every criminal case. Then the court affirmed anyway, calling the error harmless because, it wrote, nothing happened in the government's extra ten minutes that affected the outcome. One of the three judges joined the judgment only. Rehearing was denied on October 21, 2026.

The transcript answers that sentence. The rebuttal existed only because of those extra minutes, and the rebuttal is where a new theory of guilt was introduced with no chance to respond.

The other side, stated fairly. A jury convicted Elizabeth on eight counts, and the appeals court described the evidence as overwhelming. Her family disagrees, and believes a full defense closing and a correct instruction on good faith could have changed the verdict. This page shows the record so you can judge for yourself.

United States v. Hernandez, No. 24-10047 (11th Cir. July 31, 2026).

THE NUMBERWhose $200 million?

Each square is one million dollars. Tap a figure to see how much of the headline it really is.

204 squares · 1 square = $1,000,000

THE SENTENCEThe only one who went to trial

Elizabeth is a nurse practitioner who was paid by the chart. The men who ran companies in the same scheme pleaded guilty. At sentencing the judge twice noted that she was the only defendant who went to trial. Sentences, in months: Record

Elizabeth Hernandez, nurse practitioner240
Went to trial. The government asked for 240 months and got it.
Palatnik, lab owner82
Pleaded guilty.
Michael Stein60
Pleaded guilty. His judge found he “identified, recruited and liaised with Hernandez.”
Gustavo Geraldes28
Pleaded guilty. Later reduced to time served.

Guilty pleas, cooperation and the charges chosen explain part of this gap, and the law allows it. They do not explain why the person they recruited is serving four to eight times as long.

The Supreme Court is the next step

Elizabeth is a mother of five. Her petition asking the Supreme Court to hear the case is due in January 2027, and her family is seeking a pardon.

70days until the petition is due, on or about January 19, 2027.
Share on X

Sources